Skip to results list

MYSTERY SETS

12 items

Sort & Filter

Sort by
  • This image shows the candy mystery in a bowl of frosting that has candy in it.
    New
    Final Sale

    Mystery Candy Flatback Set

    Mystery Candy Flatback Set
    •  Gold/Clear
    $32
    $80 $32
  • Pink Mystery Set
    Final Sale

    Pink Mystery Set

    Pink Mystery Set
    •  Gold/Clear
    $40
    $120 $40
  • Green Mystery Set
    Final Sale

    Green Mystery Set

    Green Mystery Set
    •  Gold/Clear
    $40
    $120 $40
  • Blue Mystery Set
    Final Sale

    Blue Mystery Set

    Blue Mystery Set
    •  Gold/Clear
    $40
    $120 $40
  • Image of rotating 14K flatbacks included in the Mystery Guaranteed Gold Mystery Set that comes with 2 14K flatbacks for $98. Up to $300 value.
    14K
    Final Sale

    14K Guaranteed Gold Mystery Set - Flatback

    14K Guaranteed Gold Mystery Set - Flatback
    •  Gold/Clear
    $98
    $300 $98
  • Color Pop Mystery Set
    Final Sale
    Sold out

    Color Pop Mystery Set

    Color Pop Mystery Set
    •  Gold/Clear
    $40
    $120 $40
  • Mystery Charm Huggie Set
    Final Sale
    New to Sale

    Mystery Charm Huggie Set

    Mystery Charm Huggie Set
    •  Gold/Clear
    $26
    $32 $26
  • 14K Flatback Dangle Mystery Set
    Final Sale

    14K Flatback Dangle Mystery Set

    14K Flatback Dangle Mystery Set
    •  Gold/Clear
    $80
    $135 $80
  • Wedding Season Mystery Set
    Final Sale

    Wedding Season Mystery Set

    Wedding Season Mystery Set
    •  Gold/Clear
    $40
    $120 $40
  • Hoop There it is Mystery Set featuring 3 silver huggies for $40. Image shows an assortment of silver huggies over a basketball court.
    Final Sale

    Hoop There it Is Mystery Set

    Hoop There it Is Mystery Set
    •  Silver/Clear
    $40
    $120 $40
  • Florals for Spring Mystery Set featuring 3 gold styles for $40. Image shows an assortment of gold earrings over a gradient background.
    Final Sale

    Florals for Spring Mystery Set

    Florals for Spring Mystery Set
    •  Gold/Clear
    $40
    $120 $40
  • This is a video that features numerous different earrings that you could end up with upon purchasing a mystery set. The styles shown consist of hoops, huggies, and flatback studs in both gold and silver tones.
    Final Sale

    Mystery Earring

    Mystery Earring
    •  Gold/Silver
    $16
    $44 $16